Walmart Brand Yarn VS Red Heart Super Saver – Review and Comparison

by | Jun 23, 2018

*This post contains affiliate links to products I love and recommend.  If you make a purchase through one of those links, I may receive a commission at no cost to you.  See our disclosure for details.

Is Walmart’s Mainstays Basic Yarn comparable to Red Heart Super Saver? I think it is, at an even lower price!

I recently discovered that Walmart is now selling their own brand of value acrylic yarn, so I decided to give it a try.  It is called Mainstays Basic Yarn, and I found it to be similar in quality to Red Heart Super Saver.  The texture of the yarn is smooth, doesn’t easily split, and although it is a little scratchy (as are many yarns at this price point), I believe it will soften up nicely in the wash.  Projects made from this yarn can be machine washed and dried.  Mainstays yarn does not come in as many colors as Super Saver, though.

According to the label, each skein weighs 7 oz (198.4 g) and contains 397 yards (363 m) of yarn.  This is the same weight as Super Saver, but with a few more yards, indicating that Mainstays yarn is just slightly thinner than Super Saver (even though they are both worsted weight).  My Walmart store sells Red Heart Super Saver for around $2.79 per skein, whereas the Mainstays Basic Yarn is $1.97 per skein (slightly cheaper).

The label includes a free pattern on the back, and provides most of the information normally given on other brands’ labels.  The only information that is not provided is the dye lot number.  The label does not say anything about the dye lot, so I am assuming it is a “No Dye Lot” yarn, like Super Saver.

Overall, I think Mainstays Basic Yarn is similar in quality and slightly cheaper in price than Red Heart Super Saver, and is great for projects that need to be durable and machine-washable.

What is your favorite value acrylic yarn?

Happy Yarning! with sparkle background
photo of blog author, "hey, there!"

If squeezing yarn, collecting yarn, or making stuff from yarn is your thing, you’ll feel right at home here. My mission is to share the joy of yarn crafts with makers of all skill levels by creating clear, thoroughly-explained video tutorials and modern, approachable projects. So, whether you’re a newbie or you’ve been yarning for years, stick around and check out some of my FREE patterns & tutorials!

Want to share a post from my blog on your website?

You are welcome to share a link to any of my posts on your own website.  You may also share one photo from each post, as long as the photo is not altered or changed in any way.  Thank you!

project in progress - girl holding a black crochet hook and blue yarn with text “Hey, There!”

Yay For Yarn

Hi! Thanks for stopping by. Knitting and crochet are my passion, and I love helping others create beautiful things from yarn. If you enjoyed this post, why not check out some of my other free patterns, tips, and tutorials? Happy Yarning!

1 Comment

  1. Kathy

    I got 2 skeins of Red Heart yarn and it is the worse yarn I have gotten in years. It’s soft when you touch it and as you crochet with it it’s hard as a rock. It separates and just isn’t the quality it used to be.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Privacy Preference Center





hand holding stack of crocheted hats with faux fur pom poms

Beginner's Guide to Perfect Knit & Crochet Gifts



5 Secrets to making your handmade gifts turn out right every time!


Pin It on Pinterest

Share This